Discuss Michaels liability for the involuntary manslaughter arising out of the finish Tina
(Automatism)
Bratty defined automatism as an act done by the muscles without any control from the mind, or an act done by a person who is not in conscious tell therefore not knowing exactly what they are doing. Automatism is a complete and common defence reaction so if it is proved successfully then the trail will result in a full acquittal.
The type of automatism that would apply to Michael in this look is non-insane automatism. This is because the miss of consciousness is caused by an external cause and in this case that external cause is a nasty blow to the promontory from the accident in which he was just in. In purpose this means that Michael would be able to use the defence of automatism for his actions towards Tina resulting in him not organism criminally liable for her death.
Self disproof Jameela
A person may use force hence deemed reasonable in the circumstances in order to stay crime, this is called self defence. Self defence is a complete and general defence to crimes therefore if pleaded successfully the result will be that of an acquittal.
There are two mental testings the courts must consider when a plea of self defence is put foward, one being a inseparable test and the other being objective.
The subjective test asks Was the use of force was necessary? and the objective test asks Was the force used reasonable in the circumstances?
In Leahs case she should be able to use the defence as she honestly and instinctively believed that Jameela was attacking somebody. Leahs actions are likely to be deemed necessary as she did not know about her condition. Leah playing in a port she thought is necessary to ensure Jameela attacking even more. A reasonable man would of acted in a similar or even the same way as the defence can still be apply even if a mistake on the circumstance is make (Williams).
Jameela may also be able to use the defence as she too made a mistake of...If you require to get a full essay, order it on our website: Orderessay
If you want to get a full essay, wisit our page: write my essay .
No comments:
Post a Comment
Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.